All-Americans Honors
| Name | Sport | Year |
|---|---|---|
| CHRISTIAN ADAMS | Sport: Rugby (M) | Year: 2013-14 |
| SIALE ALATINI | Sport: Rugby (W) | Year: 2018 |
| BOB ANASTAS | Sport: Football | Year: 1958 |
| JEREMY ANTIVO | Sport: Track & Field (M) | Year: 2012 |
| BIDEMI BALOGUN | Sport: Track & Field (W) | Year: 2009-10 & 2012 |
| LISA BARNABEI | Sport: Softball | Year: 1989 |
| EMILE BARNETT | Sport: Track & Field (M) | Year: 2010 |
| KEITH BARRY | Sport: Football | Year: 1985 |
| SONIA BASMA | Sport: Soccer (W) | Year: 2013 |
| STEPHANIE BELANGER | Sport: Softball | Year: 2013 |
| BRIANNA BISHOP | Sport: Basketball (W) | Year: 2015-16 |
| MICHAEL BIWOTT | Sport: Cross Country (M), Track & Field (M) | Year: 2012-13, 2014-15 |
| SHAINA BLAMAHSAH | Sport: Track & Field (W) | Year: 2015-16 |
| MIKE BONSU | Sport: Football | Year: 2000 |
| MAURICE CALENDA | Sport: Track & Field (M) | Year: 2012 |
| RAFAEL CALIXTO | Sport: Wrestling | Year: 1997 |
| BENOIT CAMPION | Sport: Track & Field (M) | Year: 2019 |
| COREY CARTER | Sport: Wrestling | Year: 1995 |
| ALEXIS CASTRO | Sport: Basketball (W) | Year: 2006-07 |
| LAMONT CATO | Sport: Football | Year: 1989 |
| ED CEBULA | Sport: Football | Year: 1978, 1980 |
| JEPTUI CHERUITCH | Sport: Cross Country (W) | Year: 2012 |
| BLAKE CHRISTENSEN | Sport: Ice Hockey (M) | Year: 2018-19 |
| TOMMY CLARK | Sport: Rugby (M) | Year: 2017-18, 2018-19 |
| CHANDLER COTTON JR. | Sport: Track & Field (M) | Year: 2016 |
| GAVAN D'AMORE-MORRISON | Sport: Rugby (M) | Year: 2014-15, 2015-16 |
| KELLY D'ANGELO | Sport: Softball | Year: 2003 |
| JESSICA DAVIS | Sport: Rugby (W) | Year: 2013 |
| GREG DOHERTY | Sport: Football | Year: 1988 |
| GLENN DUMONT | Sport: Football | Year: 1967 |
| NAOMI ECKERT-RIVERA | Sport: Volleyball (W) | Year: 2021, 2022 |
| MARIO ELIE | Sport: Basketball (M) | Year: 1982-83, 1983-84, 1984-85 |
| LINSEY FERNANDES | Sport: Field Hockey | Year: 2009-10 & 2011 |
| ALIE FITZSIMMONS | Sport: Soccer (W) | Year: 2012-13 |
| DAVE FORBES | Sport: Ice Hockey (M) | Year: 1970-71 |
| PAUL FORT | Sport: Track & Field (M) | Year: 2012 |
| KAVIN GAILLIARD | Sport: Football | Year: 1998-99 |
| SERGINIO GILBERT | Sport: Track & Field (M) | Year: 2018-19 |
| YOSI GOASDOUE | Sport: Track & Field (M) | Year: 2011 |
| SETH HALLIMAN | Sport: Rugby (M) | Year: 2014-15 |
| ANNE HARVEY | Sport: Rugby (W) | Year: 2016 |
| JAMES HECTOR | Sport: Basketball (M) | Year: 1994 |
| GREG HILL | Sport: Basketball (M) | Year: 1968-69, 1969-70 |
| JONATHAN HORSTMAN | Sport: Track & Field (M) | Year: 2012 |
| KORI HUFFMAN | Sport: Field Hockey | Year: 2013 |
| KEMANI HUME | Sport: Track & Field (M) | Year: 2016 |
| KAYLA HUNKIN-CLARK | Sport: Rugby (W) | Year: 2016-17 |
| NOEL JAMES | Sport: Track & Field (M) | Year: 2010 |
| EMMANUEL JEAN | Sport: Track & Field (M) | Year: 2010 |
| BILL JENKINS | Sport: Football | Year: 1941 |
| CURTIS JOHNSON | Sport: Track & Field (M) | Year: 2012 |
| BRIDGET KAHELE | Sport: Rugby (W) | Year: 2016-17 |
| JIHAD KHABIR | Sport: Rugby (M) | Year: 2014-15, 2015-16 |
| LEAKEY KIPKOSGEI | Sport: Cross Country (M), Track & Field (M) | Year: 2015-16, 2017-18 & 2019 |
| DOLORES KOPREN | Sport: Volleyball (W) | Year: 2018 |
| BRUCE LAIRD | Sport: Football | Year: 1970-71 |
| STEPHANIE LASKEY | Sport: Field Hockey | Year: 2008 |
| FRAN LAVIGUEUR | Sport: Football | Year: 1975 |
| RENEE LECLERC | Sport: Softball | Year: 1995 |
| DANA LEVANGIE | Sport: Basketball (W) | Year: 2016-17, 2017-18, 2018-19 |
| KRISSY MACLEAN | Sport: Softball | Year: 1998 |
| ROB MALANDRUCCOLO | Sport: Baseball | Year: 1994-95 |
| JENNA MASIONIS | Sport: Field Hockey | Year: 2014 |
| KATHY MAYO | Sport: Softball | Year: 1995 |
| ANNA MBENGAN | Sport: Rugby (W) | Year: 2016 |
| CAROLYN MCGOWAN | Sport: Softball | Year: 1996-99 |
| DAHSIA MIDDLEBROOKS | Sport: Track & Field (W) | Year: 2019 |
| CHAD MILLER | Sport: Track & Field (M) | Year: 2016, 2018-19 |
| MIKE MITCHELL | Sport: Wrestling | Year: 1999-00, 2000-01 |
| GABE MOKWUAH | Sport: Football | Year: 1991 |
| COREY MOMSEN | Sport: Rugby (M) | Year: 2014-15 |
| BETHANY MONTAGUE | Sport: Rugby (W) | Year: 2013 |
| DYLAN MOORE | Sport: Track & Field (M) | Year: 2010 |
| MALIK MOORE | Sport: Basketball (M) | Year: 2001-02 |
| TOM MULLEN | Sport: Ice Hockey (M) | Year: 1975-76, 1977-78 |
| STARR NATHAN | Sport: Track & Field (W) | Year: 2012 |
| JOE O'GRADY | Sport: Football | Year: 1946 |
| GEORGE OUELLETTE | Sport: Football | Year: 1941 |
| BOB PARKER | Sport: Football | Year: 2000 |
| GEORGE PATTERSON | Sport: Football | Year: 1990 |
| SHELLY PFEIL | Sport: Softball | Year: 1984 |
| HORATIO PINNOCK | Sport: Track & Field (M) | Year: 2012, 2016 |
| JOE PISTONE | Sport: Wrestling | Year: 1998 |
| DAN PORTER | Sport: Football | Year: 2001 |
| JANA POTIC | Sport: Volleyball (W) | Year: 2018 |
| JON PROVOST | Sport: Football | Year: 1986-87 |
| DIVA RIVAS-REYES | Sport: Volleyball (W) | Year: 2016 |
| BENJAMIN ROACH | Sport: Rugby (M) | Year: 2013-14 |
| SHAMIRA ROBLES | Sport: Rugby (W) | Year: 2016 |
| GLARIUS ROP | Sport: Cross Country (M), Track & Field (M) | Year: 2009-10, 2011-12, 2013 |
| TOM RYCHLEC | Sport: Football | Year: 1956 |
| SHARMION SELMAN | Sport: Basketball (W) | Year: 2005-06 |
| ANDREA SERRA-ROSA | Sport: Volleyball (W) | Year: 2019, 2021, 2022 |
| RAY SHUSTER | Sport: Football | Year: 1998 |
| AARON SMITH | Sport: Wrestling | Year: 2011-12 |
| DOMINIC SMITH | Sport: Track & Field (M) | Year: 2011-12 |
| MIKE SMITH | Sport: Ice Hockey (M) | Year: 1977-78 |
| TONIQUE SOBAH | Sport: Track & Field (W) | Year: 2015 |
| ALEXANDRA STASIUK | Sport: Cross Country (W) | Year: 2013 |
| KIM STEINER | Sport: Field Hockey | Year: 2010-11 |
| DENNIS STEPHENSON | Sport: Track & Field (M) | Year: 2012 |
| PAUL THOMPSON | Sport: Football | Year: 1982 |
| ISIAH TOLBERT | Sport: Football | Year: 2019 |
| DANA WATTS | Sport: Basketball (W) | Year: 2016-17, 2017-18, 2018-19 |
| CARLTON WILDMAN | Sport: Track & Field (M) | Year: 2010 |